“Empathy is something like a muscle: left unused, it atrophies, put to work, it grows.”- Jamil Zaki
I was taught a powerful lesson more than 20 years ago. One I never want to forget.
I was Group Editor of a series of magazines in Dubai. If you’d asked me at the time whether I had a good relationship with all my team, I’d have replied firmly in the affirmative.
Then one day an editor asked to speak to me in private. I assumed she wanted my help with an issue.
In reality, I was the issue.
She told me that she sometimes found the way I spoke to her demeaning. As she spoke, she began to cry.
My previous experience had been in the newspaper industry in the UK. It was a culture that prided itself on ‘straight talking’, with the most renowned editors of the time feared as much as they were respected.
The step up to Group Editor was a big one for me at the time, and my imposter syndrome meant I was focused internally on trying to act like I thought a Group Editor should behave. It left no room for empathy.
We define this as the ability to interpret what others are thinking and feeling, and the awareness that your own state affects theirs.
I was oblivious to her feelings and the impact I was having on her, so I was completely thrown by what she shared.
Fortunately her bravery in speaking up gave me the wake-up call I needed to change my approach.
That raw, honest conversation could have gone two ways. I’m glad to say it forged a powerful bond and our friendship endures to this day.
We all have complex inner lives, so it can be challenging to truly look up and out.
But if you’re going to lead, it can never just be about you.
THE PROOF
Jeff Weiner was CEO of LinkedIn when he told the Wharton class of 2018: “I wasn’t very compassionate when I was your age.”
In 2001, he moved to Silicon Valley and became an executive at Yahoo.
Looking back on those early years, Weiner said: “I’d listen with the intent to reply, and not seek to understand.”
He wasn’t a yeller, he told them, but he was “pretty intense”.
“I expected other people to do things the way I did and grew frustrated when they didn’t,” he explained. “Over time, I realized how unproductive this approach was.”
Weiner came across The Art of Happiness at the age of 30 and, inspired by the Dalai Lama, went on to practise what he called compassionate management.
Crucially, he has said he still finds it “really, really hard to do”.
Simple doesn’t equal easy. But like any other cognitive skill, you need to keep on practising with intention and getting the reps in.
THE SCIENCE
Why does empathy matter? The answer is what it does to the people on the receiving end.
In 2012, Richard Boyatzis and colleagues asked professionals to recall experiences with two kinds of leader, ones the researchers called resonant and ones they called dissonant, while their brains were scanned.
Recalling dissonant leaders activated areas the researchers link to avoidance, narrowed attention and negative emotion. Recalling resonant leaders activated areas linked to positive emotion and social thinking.
Some of those areas sit within the brain’s social circuitry. A 2012 review by Jamil Zaki and Kevin Ochsner describes two parts to it.
One lets you share what someone else is experiencing: when you watch someone in pain, some of the same brain regions fire as when you feel pain yourself.
The other works out what they believe, intend or feel.
And empathy can be trained.
At Massachusetts General Hospital and Mass Eye and Ear, 99 trainee doctors were randomly split into two groups. One group had three one-hour training sessions over four weeks, covering how emotions work in the brain, how to read facial expressions and how to respond with empathy.
Afterwards, trained doctors showed a bigger improvement in empathy scores from patients who didn’t know which group their doctor was in.
A 2016 review of 18 randomised trials found the same: training improves measured empathy.
How do you want to be remembered, especially knowing the impact you have on those around you?
THE APPLICATION
You now know empathy can be trained. The obvious question is how.
Helen Riess, who led the Massachusetts General trial, created a seven-point checklist called E.M.P.A.T.H.Y. and made it the cornerstone of the training.
It was written for clinicians, but it resonated deeply with me, as I trained in the psychodynamic model of coaching, which has a big emphasis on unconscious behaviours.
I believe these are practical tools for any of you:
Eye contact
Meaningful eye contact tells someone you’ve noticed them and you’re engaged. Norms vary between cultures, so calibrate accordingly.
Muscles of facial expression
Decode their face as well as their words. Worry, confusion or irritation can still show there when nothing is said.
Posture
Yours should signal respect and openness. In the clinical version that meant sitting at the patient’s eye level. Think about how you sit and stand in a one-to-one. It can matter more than you realise.
Affect
Notice the other person’s emotional state, name it, and ask about it explicitly rather than assume.
Tone of voice
Tone can convey warmth or dominance. As I found out the hard way, the way you speak to someone lands as much as what you say.
Hearing the whole person
Be curious about their context, not only their words. Someone may tell you they’re fine while their unconscious cues suggest otherwise.
Your response
Notice your own reactions and manage them so they don’t drive how you respond. That’s the second half of our definition: the awareness that your own state affects theirs.
Underneath all seven is something simple and fundamentally human: people want to feel seen and heard.
There’s one trap I see time and time again and want to warn you about. Being physically close to someone day in and day out in the workplace can create the illusion that you know them fully and are tuned in to them.
In reality, your perception may be influenced by everything from assumption through to confirmation bias.
Don’t fall into it.
Be intentional about applying these, stay curious about what you can learn, and keep improving your empathetic capabilities.
Act like a cognitive athlete. Care.
Go well.
J
LIVE BETTER, LEAD BETTER
The best content I researched this week:
- This podcast on the skillsets of empathy had such a profound impact on me that I can remember exactly where I was when I first listened to it. I was walking in Portugal’s Douro Valley last year when the dynamic duo of research professor Brené Brown and organisational psychologist Adam Grant challenged some of my existing assumptions and, like all the best content, got me thinking differently.
- Rishad Tobaccowala is one of the greatest thinkers of our age in my humble opinion. This short article on how you should self-audit to ensure you are set up to succeed in the AI era is a must-read.
- The algorithm knows me too well, hence my feed this week being dominated by the release of Robert Greene’s new book, The Law of the Sublime. This article by Stoicism expert Ryan Holiday on the 23 lessons he learned from working with the Mastery author is the best of the bunch. Packed with wisdom and insights. The final lesson, on telling the people who shaped you what they mean to you, ties neatly to this week’s theme.
Free Consultation